« Where IS the federal government? | Main | This makes no sense to me... »
September 4, 2005
Natural Disaster vs. Terrorist Attack
Well, it finally started, I knew it wouldn't take long, the federal governments response to Hurricane Katrina has turned into a thermometer of it's preparedness for a major terror attack. I thought Al Queda would claim responsibility for Hurricane Katrina, but so far that has not happened. But something else has been gnawing at the edges of my thoughts for the last day or so, and tonight it has come to the forefront.
Hurricane Katrina vs. a major terror attack is an apples and oranges comparison, and here's why. Hurricanes and other natural disasters are for the most part known in advance, and those in the path of destruction have time to prepare. Major terror attacks are sudden and unexpected with little or no time for preparation. Following a major terror attack (or, to be fair, unexpected natural disaster such as an earthquake) the leaders and problem-solvers rise to the occasion, assessing the situation and deciding on appropriate actions, usually without waiting to be given charge. The others look to them for direction and follow their lead. In the event of an anticipated disaster the majority of leaders and problem-solvers heed evacuation orders and are miles away from ground zero when the dust clears.
While there may be a few prominent leaders left, they are spread too thin to be able to adequately address all the critical issues. The remaining survivors are left with little ability to assess the situation, evaluate resources and form appropriate actions. In the wake of Hurricane Katrina, the victims, shell-shocked and desperate found no leaders to guide them, until a "John Wayne" Lt. General arrived on the scene, taking control and barking orders. All of a sudden there is hope, someone is in charge, he knows the situation, has resources, and most importantly, a plan. We all know who to look to.
(And, as an aside, I am watching the players here with interest, because I think our 2008 presidential candidates will emerge from this disaster.)
Posted by Anna at September 4, 2005 2:41 AM
Comments
How insightful your writing! More later, M
Posted by: Leatha at September 5, 2005 11:06 PM
Do you think human development on environment has lead to the occurence of the natural disaster?
if yes, how does it causes the natural disaster?
Posted by: weizhen at October 15, 2005 2:36 PM
Weizhen, those are great questions, look for my response in the post titled "IMHO: Human Development's effect on Natural Disasters."
Posted by: Anna at October 15, 2005 6:54 PM